REVIEW: Jack in the Box French Fries (2010)

French fries are undoubtedly the most popular side order at any burger chain in America. I say that having done absolutely zero research, but I’m confident that it’s true. It also seems to be true that everyone has a different opinion about fries, and they love to express these opinions and, ultimately, start arguments about them. French fry arguments are like music preference arguments: nobody’s going to win, but somebody’s going to get a black eye. Okay, maybe not that drastic. But somebody’s getting banned from the ilovefrenchfries.com message board, is all I’m saying.

(PS – ilovefrenchfries.com is not a real website, so put your trolling equipment away.)

I must be bizarre, because I usually don’t order french fries. I don’t hate them, I just don’t really care for them either way. I’m comfortable having a monogamous relationship with my hamburger. Adding fries would just make the burger jealous and cause all sorts of problems. My burger and I are perfectly happy together. We don’t need any french fries coming in to “spice up the relationship.”

This could be either good or bad, in regards to this review, because today I’m taking a look at Jack in the Box’s new and supposedly improved french fries. Unfortunately, I can’t for the life of me remember what their old fries tasted like. Fortunately, that gives me a fresh palate I can then use to rain my judgment down upon these fries.

According to Tammy Bailey, division vice president of menu marketing and promotions for Jack in the Box Inc. and someone who probably has to use a very small font on her business card, “We’ve received a lot of feedback from consumers on what they like most about French fries, with flavor, texture and crispness at the top of the list. So we created our new French fries with a crispier outside texture that enhances the potato flavor and helps them retain their temperature.”

Well, Tammy, I’m afraid I’m going to have to disagree with you on some of those points. My fries were lukewarm at best, so either this magical outside texture is not working or my order had been sitting out for a while. They did have more flavor than other fries I’ve had, which did conjure some vague memories of the old Jack in the Box fries I’ve had. It’s a flavor similar to Burger King’s fries, from when they changed their recipe however many years ago. Instead of just having the flavor of grease, there’s a taste kind of like batter that makes them less bland than most other fast food fries. While the flavor was pretty good, I thought they could have used a little more salt.

The crispness is an interesting topic. Jack in the Box claims that their feedback from customers states that crispness is an important factor. Well, I got a little feedback of my own, from about a half dozen of my friends. I asked them what their favorite fast food fry was, and why. I was surprised at the results – every single one of them said they liked McDonald’s fries, because they’re limp, greasy and overly salty.

Take that with a grain of salt, har har, since these are my friends, and anyone who associates with someone who deliberately attempts to find and consume the most disgusting junk food she can find is probably of questionable taste and character to begin with. That said, the Jack in the Box fried potato sticks do live up to their claim of crispness. While I did get a few of those small, crunchy, hard fries, there wasn’t a limp stick in the bunch. Insert “limp stick” joke here.

Jack in the Box mostly succeeds in what they set out to do. While my fries were lukewarm, raising questions about how well the outer texture actually insulates the pommes frites, and I found them to be lacking in salt, they are indeed perfectly crispy and more flavorful than the average fry. The question is, is this what the people want? Well, I guess that all comes back around to the ageless polarization of people’s opinions on french fries. Some like ‘em crispy, some like ‘em greasy, some like ‘em salty, some like ‘em limp. And as long as people have assholes – er, wait, I mean, opinions, there’s going to be someone out there who likes Jack in the Box’s new, crispier fries, and someone who wants to punch that person in the face.

(Nutrition Facts – 1 small order – 333 calories, 138 calories from fat, 1 grams of saturated fat, 15 grams of total fat, 0 grams of trans fat, 1 milligram of cholesterol, 607 milligrams of sodium, 432 milligrams of potassium, 45 grams of carbohydrates, 3 grams of dietary fiber, 0 grams of sugars and 4 grams of protein.)

Item: Jack in the Box French Fries (2010)
Price: $1.79
Size: 1 small order
Purchased at: Jack in the Box
Rating: 7 out of 10
Pros: Delivers the promise of crispiness. Monogamous burger relationships. More flavorful than most fries. People getting overly agitated about flavor preferences. PR mostly living up to its own hype. Limp sticks?
Cons: Not enough salt. Getting a black eye over french fries. Magical texture jacket not keeping my fries warm. Limp sticks?

18 thoughts on “REVIEW: Jack in the Box French Fries (2010)

  1. I tried these fries and I have to say I didn’t enjoy them as much as you. Thank goodness for ketchup…and the option to switch them with curly fries.

    1. I tried to remain objective, as someone who prefers limp fries. I’ve also never eaten so many fries sans condiment. I’m more of a spicy mustard gal than a ketchup person. I did get a bonus curly fry in my order!

  2. I’m pissed that I didn’t get the latest ‘Secrect Society of Cool People’ notification about the free Fryday on April 16th. Could it be that I’m not cool enough for their Secret Society?? That’s a crushing blow to my ego.
    If I have to actually pay for these fries they’d better be hot.

  3. Jack in the Box can “improve” their fries all they want; as long as they continue to serve them barely warm nothing helps.

  4. Not sure what Mcdonalds your friends get their fries from but McDonalds fries are crisp and very salty. I have never had limp greasy fries their. That is what makes them so good is that they are crispy and salty. They are the best. Jacks old fries were horrible and limp

  5. I personally like JITB’s curly fries pretty well, so I kind of doubt I’ll ever try these, even if that’s just a scam for JITB to get another 39 cents out of me for the curly fry “upgrade” when I order a combo there.

  6. Yeah, I really should have railed them more for the temperature of the fries. Hot fries are pretty key. But I wanted to get past that and try to delve into the true nature of the fry, since my lukewarm experience could very well have been a fluke.

  7. I wished I had a Jack N’ Crack near me to try these out. However my favorite type of fries are the seasoned ones. Like Rally’s (Checkers, it all depends on where ya live!) or Arby’s curly fries. I also love Chic-A-Fil waffle fries. I really don’t think McD’s fries are all that special. I mean really they look the same and probably taste the same when you find them littered underneith your car’s seat.

  8. I personally like Sonic’s fries. Perhaps it’s because the rest of the food is so bad that the fries taste good in comparison.

    Thanks for another reason not to visit Jack in the Box. An ultimate cheeseburger tips the scales with 61 fat grams. And that’s without their secret sauce.

  9. Yeah, I haven’t had limp fries from McDonald’s in a long, long time. I do like McDonalds because they tend to get the salt just right and the flavor is good.

    The best fries, IMO, hands down is at 5 Guys. 5 Guys’ burgers are a bit overrated, but the fries are out of this world.

  10. I had the new fries last week. They were hard and overcooked. They must have just made onion rings because that is what they tasted like. :(

    New fries = FAIL

  11. crispy fries > limp fries

    Forget comparing brands. I find that the quality of fries varies between individual stores within the same brand. Aww heck… within the same store during different times of the day.

    It’s up to fate to decide whether you get a crispy or a limp fry. You’ve got to be at the right place at the right time.

    I feel lucky when I find a crispy fry. :D

  12. I do not know why they bother with their standard fries anymore.

    The curly ones are clearly made with more effort.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Comment Rules: If you tried the product we covered, please feel free to leave your opinion of it. We're totally cool with that. However, if you're going to be a complete douchebag or your comment comes off as spammy, we'll delete your stuff. Have fun and thanks for leaving a comment.