REVIEW: Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies package

Greetings, true believers.

Are you ready for one of the biggest crossover events in comic history? Yes, even bigger than Archie vs. Predator! Maybe not quite as big as Godzilla vs. Charles Barkley, but still pretty big. It’s up there.

Earth’s mightiest heroes have assembled once again, but this time in sandwich cookie form for the new “Stuf of Legends.” They’ve made the jump from the printed page and the big screen onto… Oreo wafers.

Does that sound fun? Well, this might be the laziest issue of “What If” ever.

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies in sleeves

Stuf of Legends are just regular Oreos with a twist. Not the classic Oreo twist, you can still do that, but these cookies have a gray colored crème that turns blue. That’s essentially it. And here I thought heroes never dye.

Almost 90 years of creative inspiration to pull from the pages of Marvel Comics, and this is what they landed on. Ya know what? Fine. That’s fine. Excelsior!

Who am I to judge? I couldn’t muster even a few “creative” alternatives.

I was trying to think of some Marvel heroes that changed color, and… yeah, don’t bother Googling that, lest you want to hear the worst people’s stupid opinions on which Captain America is better. No, they didn’t ruin your childhood, MagnetoMike73.

Speaking of Cap, he’s joined by a couple dozen of his fellow heroes/anti-heroes/mutants/robots/aliens/I think one dude is just a regular non-powered guy – the whole gang’s here embossed on the cookies, which I guess is the ultimate selling point. It’s cool, but I still wish they did something more interesting flavor-wise.

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies embossed cookies

I took a picture of all the characters and team logos represented in my pack. Feel free to see if you can name them all. Hint – they’re all Skrulls!

Do you want me to review an Oreo? These taste exactly the same, although I do believe they are slightly dryer. Perhaps it’s the gray crème with the little white thumbprint of it all.

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies grey creme

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies blue-ish creme

As far as the crème goes, I dipped it and also did the typical untwist-and-lick technique, and the gray-to-blue transition was uninspired at best. If I had to rank these amongst the myriad of Oreo variants we’ve seen in the past decade, I’d say they are about a Thor: Love in Thunder out of Avengers: Infinity War. I still like ’em, but they aren’t going near the top.

Oreo Stuf of Legends Cookies in milk

While the imagery of the blue crème doesn’t exactly pop off the page, it did make my mouth extremely blue – not even Beast blue, I’m talking navy Nightcrawler blue. I spared you all the pic of my disgusting maw. They didn’t even really turn the milk blue, which I assume was intentional, so as to not run into brand confusion with Disney’s other rapidly declining blockbuster property.

So, we’ve got dressed up O.G. Oreos in one of three “collectable” bags, with various, almost indecipherable characters chiseled on the cookies. They’re worth picking up as a one-time purchase if you’re a fan of the MCU – Mondelez Cookie Umbrella.

That said, if you don’t care, skip ’em. The blue isn’t fun enough to warrant what I fear is coming next. As Uncle Ben says, “With blue power comes green… well, you know.”

Cute, but hopefully DC and Hydrox cook up something a little more creative.

Purchased Price: $4.97
Size: 10.68 oz package
Purchased at: Walmart
Rating: 7 out of 10
Nutrition Facts: (2 Cookies) 140 calories, 7 grams of fat, 2.5 grams of saturated fat, 0 grams of trans fat, 0 milligrams of cholesterol, 90 milligrams of sodium, 21 grams of carbohydrates, 0 grams of fiber, 12 grams of sugar, and less than 1 gram of protein.

SPOTTED: 2/26/2026

Here are some interesting new products found on store shelves by your fellow readers. If you’ve tried any of them, share your thoughts in the comments.

Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Covered Crunchy Corn Kernels
Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Covered Crunchy Corn Kernels
Trader Joe's Sweet Onion Style Pretzel Twists
Trader Joe’s Sweet Onion Style Pretzel Twists
Trader Joe's Blonde Bar
Trader Joe’s Blonde Bar
(Spotted by Sarah R at Trader Joe’s.)
Lay's Kettle Original Sea Salt 40% Less Fat Avocado Oil Potato Chips
Lay’s Kettle Original Sea Salt 40% Less Fat Avocado Oil Potato Chips
(Spotted by Phil at Giant.)
Miss Vickie's Aged Cheddar & Black Pepper Avocado Oil Potato Chips
Miss Vickie’s Aged Cheddar & Black Pepper Avocado Oil Potato Chips
(Spotted by Robbie at Sam’s Club.)
Kettle Brand Smoky Buffalo Potato Chips
Kettle Brand Smoky Buffalo Potato Chips
(Spotted by Sarah R at Sprouts.)
Jackson's Sea Salt & Cracked Pepper Kettle Cooked Potato Chips
Jackson’s Sea Salt & Cracked Pepper Kettle Cooked Potato Chips
Jackson's Spicy Jalapeno Kettle Cooked Potato Chips
Jackson’s Spicy Jalapeno Kettle Cooked Potato Chips
(Spotted by Sarah R at Sprouts.)
Terra Sweet Chili Crunch Vegetable Chips
Terra Sweet Chili Crunch Vegetable Chips
(Spotted by Sarah R at Sprouts.)
Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Lemon Crinkle Cookies
Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Lemon Crinkle Cookies
Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Lemon Mini Donuts
Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Lemon Mini Donuts
(Spotted by Van P at Walmart.)
CT Bakery Lemon Flower Donuts
CT Bakery Lemon Flower Donuts
(Spotted by Van P at Walmart.)

If you’re out shopping and see new products, snap a picture of them, and send them in via an email ([email protected]) with where you found them and “Spotted” in the subject line. Also, if you want to send in photos and are wondering if we’ve already covered something or if they’re new, don’t worry about it. Let us worry about it.

SPOTTED: Monster Ultra Red White & Blue Razz Energy Drink

Monster Ultra Red White & Blue Razz Energy Drink.

If this is celebrating the Fourth of July, it’s early. No wait. If Halloween products come out in June, then I guess it’s on time. (Spotted by Phil at Sheetz.)

If you’re out shopping and see new products, snap a picture of them, and send them in via an email ([email protected]) with where you found them and “Spotted” in the subject line. Also, if you want to send in photos and are wondering if we’ve already covered something or if they’re new, don’t worry about it. Let us worry about it.

SPOTTED: Old Bay Seasoned Bagel Chips

Old Bay Seasoned Bagel Chips.

These were available online last summer, but are online exclusive no more. (Spotted by Phil at Boyer’s.)

If you’re out shopping and see new products, snap a picture of them, and send them in via an email ([email protected]) with where you found them and “Spotted” in the subject line. Also, if you want to send in photos and are wondering if we’ve already covered something or if they’re new, don’t worry about it. Let us worry about it.

SPOTTED: Cheez-It Black Pepper Cheddar Crackers

Cheez-It Black Pepper Cheddar Crackers.

I didn’t realize there’s a new Cheez-It product season. (Spotted by Mark at Walmart.)

If you’re out shopping and see new products, snap a picture of them, and send them in via an email ([email protected]) with where you found them and “Spotted” in the subject line. Also, if you want to send in photos and are wondering if we’ve already covered something or if they’re new, don’t worry about it. Let us worry about it.

Scroll to Top