Update: We reviewed them! Click here to read our review.
My guesses: cinnamon bun, sriracha, and chicken. (Spotted by Carla at Walmart.)
If you’re out shopping and see an interesting new product on the shelf, snap a picture of it, and send us an email ([email protected]) with where you found it and “Spotted” in the subject line. Or reply to us (@theimpulsivebuy) on Twitter with the photo, where you spotted it, and the hashtag #spotted. If you’ve tried the product, share your thoughts about it in the comments.
48 thoughts to “SPOTTED ON SHELVES: Peeps Mystery Flavors (2016)”
LOL! I laughed out loud on the 3rd flavor
My money is on bacon.
I was going to guess PEEPeroni, PEEPermint, and salt &PEEPer.
I like your picks more.
Maple bacon. sea salt caramel. Do they already come in a red velvet flavor?
Strawberry shortcake or maple bacon.
I’d like a pina colada or mango flavour.
I am unfortunately obsessed with Peeps so I bought these as soon as I saw them today. My guesses on the flavors are buttered popcorn, chocolate – maybe devil’s food? – and the last one is fruity and sour and I can’t place it. It almost tastes like those rainbow sour strips of candy.
I agree on the chocolate (kinda hot chocolate like) and buttered popcorn. Have yet to try the other yet.
3rd tastes like sour tangerine
3 tastes like angel food
I agree with you.
The last one is sour cherry
Sour cherry is EXACTLY what I said I thought number 3 was as well. Haven’t tried the others yet. Would love to try the buttered popcorn. That’s my favorite Jelly Belly jellybean flavor!
#1 is a chocolate. #2 butter popcorn. #3 is cherry. I think.
That’s what I thought too. Popcorn and …something tangy. I don’t like either lol.
I got the buttered popcirn for sure
Definitely buttered popcorn for 2. I guessed mocha for 1 and kids are saying Sour Patch Kids for 3 lol.
The last one is definitely cherry.
The last one is probably Cherry limeade
One was chocolate the other popcorn they didnt have the third 🙁
#3 is buttered popcorn
#3 is sour
#1 is for sure chocolate (like dum dum sucker chocolate). I haven’t tried #2 yet, but #3 is a fruity flavor… Almost a raspberry?
3 tastes like angel food
1. Hot Chocolate 2. Buttered Popcorn 3. Raspberry Lemonade
Not a 100% sure on the 3rd one but between my boyfriend and I, it was our best guess.
My guess for #1 is s’mores.
I’ve tried mystery flavor one and it doesn’t taste like cinnamon bun to me. It’s actually more like s’mores.
#1 smores or hot chocolate
#2 buttered popcorn
#3 black cherry or some kind of berry
My kids and I agree the 3rd flavor is watermelon. I agree with the other two.
I completely agree! I guess was chocolate, cherry and possibly peanut butter
Totally my guesses too. Sour cherry for sure.
Exactly what I thought
#1 i think is hot chocolate and #3 i think is sour cherry. Still haven’t tried #2 yet
I agree with the people who voted “Buttered Popcorn” for #2, though my initial reaction was “Pretzel.”
Your comments are making me salivate. I’ve been a Peeps fan forever. Must try new flavor. . . . Must try new flavor. . . .
i was thinking e 3rd is like black cherry cola,dr.pepper,or 7up; but then got to thinking maybe the powder sugar stuff in a baby bottle pop or something O:< ive had it and smelt it I just can't put a name on it.
I think #3 is orange hazelnut
My guesses are hot chocolate, Buttered popcorn, and sour cherry.. idk if I am right tho.
I agree with buttered popcorn. I’m thinking the fruity one might be cherry limeade?
1. I couldn’t taste much difference between from a regular peep, maybe a heavier vanilla flavor?
2. Definitely popcorn, I could smell it more than I could taste it, though.
3.. Lemon or something citrus.
#1 vanilla of something
#3 lemon or lime
#2 is buttered popcorn. I only grabbed #2 and extremely disappointed as they are really freaking nasty.
xD they are all SOOOOOOO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
#1 is definitely chocolate. You have to smell as well as taste, because it’s the olfactory nerves in your nose that differentiate specific flavors.
Haven’t tried the others yet.
#1 is hot chocolate; #2 is buttered popcorn; #3 is strawberry shortcake… In my opinion.
Husband said “#1 is Red Velvet Cake – #2 is Buttered Popcorn – #3 is Cherry Limeade”
I said “#1 is Devil’s Food Cake – #2 is Buttered Popcorn – #3 is Tangerine”
Neighbor said “#1 is Chocolate Chip Cookies – #2 is Macaroni & Cheese – #3 is Lemon”
92 year old lady said “#1 is Hot Chocolate – #2 is Popcorn – #3 is Lime Jello”
10 year old girl said “#1 is Chocolate Cupcake – #2 is Popcorn – #3 is Sour Apple”
her 10 year old twin brother said “#1 is Fudgecicle – #2 is Pretzels – #3 is Lemon-Lime”
Peeps Mystery Flavor Survey of Guesses
Comments are closed.