REVIEW: Harvey’s Strawberry Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich (Canada)

Harvey's Strawberry Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich

Harvey’s, a popular Canadian burger chain, recently came out with an ice cream sandwich made with Strawberry Pop-Tarts; this is not to be confused with the Hardee’s/Carl’s Jr. Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich, also made with Strawberry Pop-Tarts (and thanks to Harvey’s’ lawyers, Hardee’s is actually not allowed to call themselves Hardee’s in Canada, and instead must go by Carl’s Jr., which is basically the same restaurant, just with a different name).

What was I talking about? Oh yes, Pop-Tarts, ice cream, and the sandwich born from their union.

It was actually better than I thought it would be. For one thing, I was afraid the sandwich would be made with untoasted Pop-Tarts. There are two types of people in the world: people who like their Pop-Tarts toasted, and people who are wrong. I don’t know what the afterlife entails, but I know that those raw Pop-Tart eating maniacs will never get there — they will be condemned to wander for all eternity in a horrifying purgatory, cursed with the terrible knowledge that it was their ill-advised opinion on Pop Tarts that brought them there.

Thankfully, the Pop-Tarts here are toasted — lightly toasted, but enough to remove that doughy flavour and texture that uncooked Pop Tarts have.

I thought that perhaps the sandwiches would be assembled on the spot, however they are actually created in advance and frozen, Pop-Tarts and all. A sandwich made with a warm Pop-Tart, with the ice cream starting to get melty, and with a satisfying contrast between hot and cold would have been nice, but alas.

Harvey's Strawberry Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich Closeup

Though I was afraid that the freezing process would make the filling of the Pop-Tart unpleasantly hard, I was again happy to be proven wrong. The deep freeze actually gives the filling a pleasantly toothsome chew; this worked quite well in the context of an ice cream sandwich.

The ice cream itself was fine. It has a generically sweet, creamy taste, without much vanilla flavour. But it’s smooth and not icy at all, and honestly, if you were expecting much better than that from a Pop-Tart sandwich from Harvey’s, then you clearly have your own issues you need to work out. It is what it is. If you’ve ever had those budget ice cream sandwiches from the supermarket, you know what to expect from the ice cream.

The whole thing results in a dessert that’s actually fairly satisfying. It’s not overly sweet and there’s a little bit of tartness (Pop-Tartness?) from the filling. There’s a good contrast of textures between the Pop-Tart and the ice cream, and the price feels right at two bucks.

(Nutrition Facts – Nutrition facts not available on Harvey’s website.)

Item: Harvey’s Strawberry Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich
Purchased Price: $1.99 CAN
Size: N/A
Purchased at: Harvey’s
Rating: 7 out of 10
Pros: Contains a Pop-Tart that is toasted rather than raw. Decent quality vanilla ice cream. The frozen Pop-Tart has a satisfying chewiness. Only two bucks.
Cons: The ice cream isn’t exactly gourmet. A sandwich assembled fresh with a hot Pop-Tart would have been nice.

4 thoughts to “REVIEW: Harvey’s Strawberry Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich (Canada)”

  1. Confession: When you posted this picture last week I immediately plotted a homemade version. I used vanilla bean ice cream and the 50th Birthday Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme Pop-Tarts. I did not toast the tarts prior to assembly. My only consolation while wandering a “horrifying purgatory” will be the memory of that tooth-achingly sweet, delicious (albeit un-toasted) confectionery treat.

  2. For all the bluster, the picture shows a decidedly plain old untoasted pop tart.

    1. Trust me, I know the difference between a toasted and untoasted Pop-Tart. It was toasted (albeit lightly toasted, as I mentioned in the review).

  3. Crossed the border and was in Toronto this past weekend. Trying this was on my to-do list, based on your review. I’m not sure if the promotion is winding down or if it was the location I went to (or maybe they ran out of premade ones?), but I sadly watched an employee assemble the ice cream sandwich without toasting the Pop Tart. Very sweet, tasty, yet slightly disappointing. It was our first time at a Harvey’s and my husband went with the chocolate shake, which was very good!

Comments are closed.