REVIEW: Reese’s Snack Cake

Reese s Snack Cake Package

What are Reese’s Snack Cakes?

Each snack consists of a chocolate cake layer topped with Reese’s peanut butter creme and covered in milk chocolate.

How are they?

Reese s Snack Cake Exterior

When I unwrapped my package of Reese’s Snack Cakes, I was expecting a take on a Hostess CupCake or Zinger: a supple, airy sponge slicked with icing. What I found looked more like a candy bar: two chocolate-coated rectangles nestled in a cardboard sleeve, compact and entirely coated with milk chocolate.

Intrigued by the snack’s appearance (and anything involving peanut butter), I felt this warranted deeper investigation. Because I’m weird, I like to analyze snacks layer by layer, pretending that I’m a junk food scientist studying a sugary ecosystem. Here are my findings:

The milk chocolate coating is smooth and creamy. It tastes like what you’d find in the candy aisle, but a little sturdier and less prone to melting.

Next, the peanut butter creme has the delicious flavor of Reese’s filling, but with textural differences that remind me of marzipan or even hard fudge. It is soft, but dense and malleable enough that the layer can retain its shape when separated from the cake.

Reese s Snack Cake Innards

Finally, the cake layer is difficult to classify. Its deep cocoa flavor pairs well with the other cake components, but its texture is unsuccessful. Dense, dry, and crumbly, it is barely a cake. It tastes like a cake deprived of moisture or air, with all of its crumbs squeezed together. It brings to mind protein-enhanced snack bars (think Protein One), and with six grams of protein, it could probably pass as one more easily than it could pass as a cake.

Overall, the peanut butter and chocolate outshine an unsuccessful cake, which should have been the star of this snack. A different product name would have helped to leverage expectations, but the result is not Reese’s strongest offering.

Anything else you need to know?

Reese s Snack Cake Size

In press releases, Reese’s has billed its Snack Cakes as breakfast or mid-morning snacks. Given both the product’s candy bar sweetness and lack of resemblance to cake, I don’t understand the breakfast connection. Coffee cakes, muffins, and scones will not need to fight these snack cakes for space at the brunch table.


Decidedly un-cakelike, Reese’s Snack Cakes deliver on the classic chocolate and peanut butter pair, but are worth less than the sum of their parts.

Purchased Price: $1.99
Size: 2.75 oz pack (2 cakes)
Purchased at: Sheetz
Rating: 5 out of 10
Nutrition Facts: 380 calories, 21 grams of fat, 11 grams of saturated fat, 0 grams of trans fat, less than 5 milligrams of cholesterol, 170 milligrams of sodium, 45 grams of carbohydrates, 2 grams of fiber, 33 grams of sugar, and 6 grams of protein.

18 thoughts to “REVIEW: Reese’s Snack Cake”

  1. Hmm, yeah, had a feeling that this might be a fail when I heard about it a while back. Maybe Hostess will be inspired to do a peanut butter ho-ho if they haven’t already.

  2. I agree and disagree! It definitely doesn’t deserve to be called a cake. However, if you go into it thinking it’s just a candy bar then wow! I think it’s better than an original Reese cup. Possibly my new favorite snack. Also, shop Rutters not Sheetz 🙂

    1. I couldn’t agree more. Fail on the snack cake but home run on the candy bar. The crunchy ones are great too.

  3. The way it looks, and how you describe it, it sounds like a protein bar, but without the protein. I’ll pass.

    1. I really can’t wrap my head around why they would make the peanut butter layer like that.

  4. I don’t really understand the purpose of these. They took a perfectly good candy and made it worse. I will pass.

    1. If I wanted a funny bone, it would probably be easier to just rip one out of someone’s body where I live. 😛

      1. No kidding. They could have added some peanut butter stripes on top, at the very least, to give it a touch more peanut butter and a little bit of color. Oh, well.

  5. Husband surprised me with this because I love Reese’s. What a disappointment. It’s not a bad idea, but I definitely get the protein bar connection. Bland, dry, crumbly, and just plain terrible. Couldn’t even really taste the peanut butter.

Comments are closed.