Well folks, “Spooky Season” is just about over.
Crazy, right? It feels like it just started.
No, seriously, it feels like “Spooky Season” literally just started. That term seemingly appeared out of thin air and now every single person insists on saying it fourteen times a day.
For that reason alone, I was relieved to see Christmas snacks like Snickerdoodle Oreo Cookies starting to hit the shelves.
Are snickerdoodles even a Christmas thing? I’ve never really thought of them as distinctly Christmassy, but who am I to argue?
Snickerdoodle Oreo has both cinnamon-flavored cookies and crème, which are both speckled with red and green crunchy flavor crystals, so ya know what? Sure, these are Christmas cookies.
I love a good snickerdoodle. I love Oreo. Surely, I love these, right?
Ehhhh, I have some gripes. Bah humbug and whatnot.
First of all, there’s something very “synthetic cinnamon” about the scent these cookies emit. There’s a fine line between appetizing and “candle,” and these smell like the latter.
The cookie wafer itself has a very mild cinnamon flavor. There’s no mention on the package, so I may honestly just be tasting a cinnamon Ghost of Christmas Past radiating from the crème. These might just be decorated Golden Oreo, but I think I’m right. Either way, it’s a pretty bland cookie.
The crème is nice, but not exactly bursting with cinnamon. It’s like the classic Oreo crème with a dash of cinnamon. They’re not cloyingly sweet as a result, so that’s a positive.
Don’t get me wrong, there’s no mistaking the cinnamon, but these are a little on the boring side. I do love the colorful flavor crystals though. They’re basically the sprinkles you’d decorate Christmas sugar cookies with, and they made the wafers look like Doritos Cool Ranch Oreo, which excited me for some strange reason.
I should acknowledge that while I find these tame, they do a nice job of emulating the cookie’s flavor. It’s not like snickerdoodles typically burn your mouth like a shot of Fireball or a stick of Big Red, so I’m not sure what I was ultimately expecting.
Another thought I couldn’t shake was that snickerdoodles are usually as much a textural cookie as they are a flavor experience. If I’m eating one, I want it to be soft. I associate this cinnamon profile with a soft cookie, so maybe these never even had a chance to be a favorite.
Snickerdoodle might literally be the center point on an Oreo flavor scale. I don’t really remember the exact taste of the Cinnamon Bun Oreo, but I’m positive I liked those more. In reality, these probably aren’t that much of a far cry from those, but they’re definitely worse.
With these being released in October, I’m curious to see if Oreo has an even more Christmassy variety up its three sleeves. If not, you’re stuck with Snickerdoodle, which is… fine. They’re fine. They’re inoffensive and probably worth a try, but they certainly don’t pack enough of a punch to eat during something called “Spooky Season,” so maybe wait a week or two. Merry Christmas.
Purchased Price: $4.69
Size: 12.2 oz package
Purchased at: Shop Rite
Rating: 5 out of 10
Nutrition Facts: (2 Cookies) 140 calories, 7 grams of fat, 2 grams of saturated fat, 0 gram of trans fat, 0 milligrams of cholesterol, 85 milligrams of sodium, 21 grams of carbohydrates, 0 grams of fiber, 12 grams of sugar, and less than 1 gram of protein.
7 thoughts to “REVIEW: Limited Edition Snickerdoodle Oreo Cookies”
“Are snickerdoodles even a Christmas thing? I’ve never really thought of them as distinctly Christmassy.”
THIS. Thanks for saying what I have thought for years!
Same. For me, they’re in the “standard” bracket with chocolate chip cookies, peanut butter ones, and oatmeal cookies (with raisins, don’t @ me ?) meaning they are enjoyed year-round.
(That ? was supposed to be a laughing emoji)
I can’t make emojis work either. As far as the cookies they weren’t appealing until I read this. I like mild cinnamon so they sound like just the ticket.
Let’s start calling Christmastime “Santa Season.”
I didn’t like them at all but snickerdoodles are my all time favorite cookie. I only ate one and ended up giving the rest of the pack away. The first thing I thought of when I tasted it was it was more like an oatmeal cookie. I also really tasted a lot of artificial flavoring.
What is wrong with people? These were amazing! Yes very sweet, but very good. I travel to other stores to find them.
Wish I could order a case of them and then freeze them.
Thank you Nabisco for a holiday treat.